Choosing the right type of flagstone for your outdoor spaces is much like selecting the perfect artwork for your living room: it’s a choice that can transform the mundane into the spectacular, creating an ambiance that perfectly complements your home's style.
And conversely, the wrong choice might not only clash with your home’s aesthetic but also lead to practical issues down the line, such as poor durability, a finish that brings challenges in our Michigan climate, etc.
To make an informed decision that marries beauty with functionality, it’s crucial to familiarize yourself with the different types of flagstone and their characteristics. So in this guide, we’re providing an overview of the primary types of flagstone available and how each can enhance your outdoor living environment.
Natural Flagstone
Natural flagstone features irregular shapes and sizes that infuse your outdoor space with a charming, natural look. A favorite of those who prefer a non-uniform, organic aesthetic, flagstone offers an enchanting and relaxed look that helps patios and walkways blend in with natural surroundings. At the same time, natural flagstone presents creative challenges (as well as opportunities) in your overall landscape design.
Here’s more on when natural flagstone works—and when it might not.
When Natural Flagstone Works Well
1. Natural, Organic Landscapes: Natural flagstone is perfect for achieving a rustic, natural look. It blends seamlessly into garden paths, woodland settings, or any area where you desire a less structured and more organic appearance.
2. Informal Patio Areas: For patios where a casual, inviting atmosphere is the goal, natural flagstone's irregular shapes and varied colors add character and warmth that’s difficult to replicate with more uniform materials.
3. Variable Space Filling: Natural flagstone can be ideal for environments where the precise shape of the area isn’t strictly defined. The irregular sizes and shapes of the stones fill spaces in a non-structured way, delivering an aesthetic appeal that’s in keeping with the natural space.
4. Unique Design Elements: If you’re looking to create a patio or pathway with a one-of-a-kind look, natural flagstone offers a unique option that ensures no 2 designs are exactly alike. Each stone’s special texture and shape brings another layer of interest to the area, creating a striking visual effect that is full of personality.
When Natural Flagstone May Not Be Ideal
1. Formal Landscape Designs: In settings that require a uniform and formal look, such as classical garden pathways or corporate outdoor spaces, natural flagstone’s irregularity might clash with the design ethos.
2. Accessibility Requirements: For areas where accessibility is a high priority—especially areas with a focus on ease of mobility via wheelchairs, walkers, etc.—the uneven surface of natural flagstone can pose a significant challenge and will not be ideal.
3. High-Precision Installation Areas: When precision and uniformity in installation are critical, natural flagstone can be difficult to work with, due to its varied shapes and thicknesses. This can lead to increased labor for fitting and setting the stones properly, which is not ideal for all projects.
4. Maintenance Considerations: The gaps and joints between natural flagstones can be larger and more irregular, potentially leading to more weeding or refilling of joint material. So landscapes requiring low maintenance usually aren’t a good fit for natural flagstone.
Shaped (Cut) Flagstone
For a more structured and formal appearance, shaped flagstone is an excellent option. This flagstone is precisely cut and shaped into rectangles or squares, facilitating faster installation and a tidy, modern look. It retains the unique, natural aesthetic of flagstone but with a more consistent finish suitable for contemporary landscapes.
So when is shaped flagstone the right choice, and when is it not?
When Shaped Flagstone Works Well
1. Formal and Modern Designs: Shaped flagstone is perfect for formal landscapes or modern architectural settings where the goal is uniformity and clean lines. Its regular shapes and sizes provide a neat, organized look that complements structured garden designs.
2. Accessibility Needs: For areas that require ease of accessibility, such as paths or patios that need to accommodate wheelchairs or other mobility aids, the even surface of shaped flagstone is ideal. Its consistent thickness and smooth edges make it a relatively safe and practical choice.
3. Easier Installation: Shaped flagstone often allows for quicker and more straightforward installation compared to natural flagstone. The uniformity in shape and size means that less time is spent fitting pieces together, which can reduce labor costs and installation time.
4. Smaller Joints and Easier Maintenance: With tighter joints that are easier to grout and maintain, shaped flagstone requires less upkeep in terms of joint care. This makes it a good option for any areas where minimal maintenance is preferred, including high-traffic areas.
When Shaped Flagstone May Not Be Ideal
1. Less Natural Appearance: If the goal is a rugged, organic look that blends seamlessly with natural surroundings, shaped flagstone might be too orderly and artificial-looking. Its uniformity can detract from the natural aesthetic that many landscape designs aim to capture.
2. Limited Creative Freedom: The regular shapes and sizes of cut flagstone can limit creative design options. While it provides a neat appearance, it may not offer the same level of uniqueness or character as irregularly shaped flagstone, nor is it likely to fill oddly shaped spaces as well as natural flagstone.
3. Higher Cost: Depending on the source and type of stone, shaping flagstone can add to the cost due to the additional processing involved. This can make it a less economical choice compared to natural flagstone, especially for larger areas.
4. Potentially Slippery When Wet: Depending on the finish, shaped flagstone can end up with a smoother finish that, when wet, is more slippery than the textured surface of natural flagstone. Keep this in mind when designing pool decks or other wet environments.
Bluestone
Bluestone is a specific type of dense, hard flagstone quarried in Pennsylvania, New York, and Quebec. It is favored for its fine grains and durability, and comes in beautiful shades of blue and gray, making it an appealing choice for both rustic and modern designs. Bluestone is perfect for creating a sophisticated yet sturdy patio space.
But what are the pros and cons?
When Bluestone Works Well
1. Elegant and Refined Spaces: Bluestone is particularly suited to creating elegant, refined outdoor living areas. Its rich colors and smooth texture provide a luxurious finish that enhances both modern and traditional architectures.
2. High-Traffic Areas: Due to its density and hardness, bluestone is extremely durable, making it ideal for high-traffic areas like walkways, driveways, and patios. It withstands heavy use without showing significant wear and tear, maintaining its aesthetic appeal over time.
3. Consistent Color and Texture: Bluestone offers consistency in color and texture, which is ideal for projects requiring a uniform appearance. This can be particularly appealing in formal garden settings or commercial spaces where a professional, cohesive look is important.
4. Wet Conditions: Bluestone's texture provides good traction even when wet, making it a safe choice for pool surrounds, outdoor kitchens, and other areas frequently exposed to wet elements. This safety feature is enhanced by bluestone’s low absorption rate, which minimizes water damage and slipping hazards.
When Bluestone May Not Be Ideal
1. Limited Color Range: While bluestone’s color palette is elegant, it is limited to shades of blue and gray. If a project requires warmer tones or a specific color to match existing landscaping, bluestone may not offer the necessary variety.
2. Cost Considerations: Due to its density and the processing required for shaping and finishing, bluestone generally proves more expensive than other types of flagstone. So budget considerations can make this stone the wrong choice for large-scale projects or anyone seeking a particularly cost-effective option.
3. Cold Climate Installation: If not properly installed with appropriate base materials and drainage, bluestone can be susceptible to cracking in extremely cold climates. While it is indeed a durable stone, improper installation in freeze-thaw environments can lead to longevity issues. So it’s essential to seek expert installation.
4. Weight Considerations: The density of bluestone also means it is heavier than many other types of stone, which might require additional labor or reinforcement during installation. This can increase the overall cost and complexity of the project.
Choosing the right type of flagstone for your patio or landscaping project is crucial for achieving the desired aesthetic and functionality. Whether you opt for natural flagstone, shaped flagstone, or bluestone, each type offers unique benefits and challenges.
If you're unsure which flagstone is best suited for your specific needs, a consult with a professional hardscape contractor is an excellent first step. The team at Decra-Scape is here to help.
For more inspiration, check out ourgallery of our work, read more on theblog, or catch up with us onInstagram.
